
If there’s one thing last night’s dinner proved about Otto Enoteca Pizzeria, it’s that this place is all about consistency: consistently crowded, consistently fun, and, of course, consistently good food.
It’s the kind of place you should come to with friends. Otto is really designed for groups, both in its layout (a huge back room with plenty of tables that fit six or even eight people) and it’s style of food. This restaurant is all about small things — lots of antipasti that are passed from person to person, hunks of cheese from both Italy and the U.S., and pizzas sized so that you can order at least two.
Small is good, because it means you and your friends can have lots of tastes of lots of food. The tables at Otto quickly turn into a frenzied mess, like in the photo above from last night, with plates and bowls of food scattered around, and all our hands reaching back and forth between each other, each dish passed around again and again.
We started off last night with prosecco, which is Italian sparkling wine, and a trio of olives out in the bar, while we waited for others to arrive. The bar area might seem a bit unusual — aside from the stools at the counter, there are no chairs, and only high tables around which people stand. This is an ode to the ways things are done in Italy, where you’ll find no chairs in most bars (ah, memories of grabbing due macchiati in Roma…)
Once we moved inside, the eating began. We had a selection of vegetable antipasti: eggplant caponatina, brussels sprouts “con vin cotto,” autumn vegetables “con aceto.” A plate of prosciutto and a plate of “sopressa,” house-cured (I think?) salami (which was out of this world!). Also a selection of seven cheeses from their list, including a Coach Triple Cream, a pecorino, a very creamy taleggio, and, everyone’s favorite, ricotta (which, combined with their truffle honey, is amazing).
We then moved on to the hot plates. Two pastas — “rigatoni con sausage and escarole,” which had a bit of heat, and “linguini con cavolo e speck,” which, with the cheese in it, had an almost carbonara-like consistency. Both were definitely porky goodness on a plate.
And finally, two pizzas. One “pepperoni,” which is a spicy salami, but not the one you’re thinking of (hint: it’s much better), and an “aglio, olio, and peperoncini,” which is simply olive oil, garlic, and red chilies. Both are thin-crusted, and nice and charred on the bottom. Otto does pizza right.
Actually, that wasn’t the finale, because you cannot go to Otto without trying the thing that put them on the map — olive oil gelato. Now, if you’ve never had it, your likely reaction to hearing this is, “Huh?” But, I can attest: Once you try it, you will be forever addicted.
I’ve eaten at there a lot. Seriously. A lot. And, as I said before, if it’s anything, it’s consistent.
You can always count on a great night of eating at Otto.
Otto Enoteca Pizzeria
One Fifth Ave
NYC
- Carlo